Jasmine Birtles
Your money-making expert. Financial journalist, TV and radio personality.
How do you know if you need a DBS check?
MoneyMagpie team
2nd Aug 2019
Here at MoneyMagpie, we like to keep in contact with our readers. One of the most frequently asked questions we receive is from people wondering: “Do I need a DBS check?”
It’s a good question as it’s not always clear who needs one and who doesn’t, particularly when it comes to volunteering, so we’ve put together this handy guide for job hunters and potential employees.
Here is how you can find out if you need a DBS check.
What is a DBS check?
Criminal record checks have been around for some time helping employers to find suitable people to work with children and vulnerable groups. However, this process has become increasingly complicated and lengthy so the government has replaced the Criminal Records Bureau (CRB) check with the one from the Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS).
The Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) was established under the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 and carries out the functions previously undertaken by the Criminal Records Bureau (CRB) for England and Wales and the Independent Safeguarding Authority (ISA) for England, Wales and Northern Ireland.
The primary role of the DBS is to help employers in England and Wales make recruitment decisions by issuing criminal records checks and to prevent people from working with vulnerable groups who may not be safe to do so.
Amongst these vulnerable groups are children, babies, the elderly, people with learning disabilities of any age or people with other mental health difficulties.
The main function of the DBS check is to provide an answer to the employer or organisation with whom you’re volunteering to the following question: “Do you have any criminal convictions, cautions, reprimands or final warnings?”
Usually, you only really need a DBS check if you’re planning on working with vulnerable people and children, however other jobs might also demand it and this is becoming more and more common.
A DBS check will determine whether or not an individual is on one of two barred lists in England, Wales and Northern Ireland: one bars people from working with children and the other with vulnerable adults.
When a check has been processed by the DBS the individual will receive a DBS certificate illustrating whether they are cleared to work with particular groups.
Under the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act of 1974, criminals who have served a prison sentence of less than two and a half years and do not re-offend during a set ‘rehabilitation’ period after their release may have their conviction spent, which means it doesn’t show up any more and is no longer relevant when the person is being considered for most jobs. It’s quite complex so you can read more about the DBS filtering system here.
If you have unspent convictions – meaning you are still serving your probationary ‘rehabilitation’ period following sentencing – this can cause issues. However, if this is the case, it’s up to the employer whether this is or isn’t a problem. With work being seen as an essential part of prisoner rehabilitation, this is becoming far less of a barrier in current times. For example, Manchester’s ‘The Clink’ restaurant exclusively hires prisoners from HMP Styal as staff to rehabilitate them.
Do i need a DBS check?
Generally speaking, if you plan on working with or around children or vulnerable people you will need a DBS check. Employers may wish to look at the DBS eligibility guidance list which runs down most roles that are eligible for a check. However, the guidance isn’t comprehensive, and you should contact the DBS directly if you’re unsure.
If you’re the person being checked, your potentially new employer will give you a form to fill in and return to them along with documents proving your identity such as a passport, current driving licence and proof of address. You can find more information on what documents are accepted here.
How do DBS checks work?
Your employers will apply to have a check done on your behalf but then the certificate will be sent to you, not your employer. These checks can take up to 8 weeks to complete from filling out the form, so if you’re working in a care role it’s important to bear this in mind. You won’t be able to start working till the check is completed.
Depending on the level of the check, the cost varies with a standard check costing £26 and an enhanced check costing £44. Some employers will ask you to pay these fees. However the norm is for employers to pay these costs.
However, if you’re applying for a DBS for a voluntary role, there are no associated fees regardless of the level of check needed.
Employers will only arrange a DBS check on a successful job applicant. If the applicant is found to be unsuitable, the job offer can be withdrawn so save yourself the time and stress and be honest on your applications!
These are the basic steps for an employer who wants to perform a DBS check:
- Get the application form from DBS or your umbrella body.
- Ask the candidate to fill in the application form (N.B. make sure you have everything exact in this form because if you get any of your former addresses wrong it will be sent back you will have to go through the whole thing again – it’s very annoying!)
- Send the application form to your umbrella body or DBS.
- If your organisation is registered with DBS the counter signatory has to sign the form. DBS will send you a certificate.
What is the Disclosure and Barring Service?
So now you have a better idea of what a DBS check means to you but you’re still thinking you want more detail. Well never fear, Money Magpie’s here to oblige.
We’ve covered some of the following in what the DBS means to you but here’s a quick breakdown of the kind of work the DBS does.
Disclosure
Once the DBS is complete the applicant will give this certificate to their employer so that they can make an informed decision about hiring you.
You can find out here what kind of information the DBS searches through.
The certificate will contain sensitive and personal information so there is a code of practice for recipients. This ensures that this information remains confidential and you know the information is being handled fairly and used properly.
Referrals
Referrals are made to DBS when an employer or organisation believes a person has caused harm or poses a future risk of harm to vulnerable groups, including children.
Barring
An employer or volunteer manager is breaking the law if they knowingly employ someone in a regulated activity with a group from which they are barred from working.
The DBS do try and make the baring decisions as fair as they can be, looking into each individual case.
There are two main ways a case can reach them.
Autobars
There are two types of automatic barring cases where a person has been cautioned or convicted for a relevant offence:
- Automatic barring offences (without the right to make representations) will result in the person being included in one or both barred lists by DBS, irrespective of whether they have, are, or may in the future engage in regulated activity
- Automatic barring offences (with the right to make representations) may also result in the person being placed on one or both barred lists. This will be subject to whether DBS believes that the person has engaged, is engaging or may in future engage in regulated activity, and the consideration of any representations they make
Referrals
As mentioned above, this is put forward by an employer or organisation rather than the individual.
A registered body is an organisation that has the right to ask the questions that are exempt under the Exceptions Order to the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act or can countersign on the behalf of another organisation which is itself entitled to ask these questions.
Basically they’re in charge of making sure that your application is kosher and will countersign it once they’ve processed it to say that all your information is genuine.
Before they do this they will:
- Check and validate the information you give them
- Make sure you are who you say you are
- Check that your application form is correctly filled in and that you haven’t told any porkies
Make sure that the application process complies with the DBS’s code of practice.
You can find out more about how to make a referral to the DBS in this booklet.
What’s the difference between the CRB and the DBS?
The DBS replaced the CRB in December 2012 to make the process more efficient and simpler.
The DBS has a new system which, for the first time, enables individuals to apply to have their criminal record check kept up to date, and employers are able to go online to see if the information released is still current and valid.
The new online service costs £13 a year to keep your criminal record up to date. This means you can take the certificate with you from role to role, within the same workforce, without having to apply for a new one each time. We highly recommend this to people who are working on short-term contracts.
When subscribing to this service, you would only have to seek a new criminal record check if the system tells you something has changed.
How do I get a DBS check?
You can’t do a criminal records check on yourself. For individuals who are self-employed, getting a DBS check is difficult but not impossible.
You can find a local DBS umbrella body on the Gov.uk site here. For a fee, one of these agencies will do it for you.
In Scotland, if you need to run a check on yourself, you can get a ‘basic disclosure’ with details of any unspent convictions from Disclosure Scotland.
You can also get checked through an organisation you belong to, like your church or a sports club, whereby they act as your third party.
If you cannot get your hands on the DBS check, a good alternative is a Subject Access Report which you can obtain by filling out a form online or going down to your local police station. The report costs £10 and shows anything that is on your record. It should take around four weeks to process. However, be aware that this is not always good enough.
For example, many psychologists are technically self-employed but work with children under contract with NHS/Social Services. For them, a basic check is ineffective as a safeguarding measure so they need to have had an full enhanced check to do the work they do.
How much do DBS checks costs?
As mentioned earlier, here are three types of check each with a different price.
| Type of check and cost | What it will check for | How long it normally takes |
| Standard – £26 | Spent and unspent convictions, cautions, reprimands, final warnings | About two weeks |
| Enhanced – £44 | As above – plus any additional information held locally by police forces that’s reasonably considered relevant to the post applied for | About four weeks |
| Enhanced with list checks – £44 | As above – plus a check of the appropriate DBS barred lists | About four weeks |
For volunteers it’s free of charge.
However, on top of these charges you will pay administration fees to the agency which will vary according to the different registered bodies, but are usually in the region of £20 plus VAT.
N.B. DBS checks are only valid in England, Wales and Northern Ireland.
For Scotland you must get your check done by Disclosure Scotland. All checks carried out cost £25.
Hi
When i was 15 i was in the wrong place at the wrong time and in a house were a man was arrested and charged with intent to supply. as i was present in the same house i was also taken to the police station arrested and held on police bail. although in the end they couldnt charge me as i wasnt guilty of anything. Would this show up on a enhanced crb, it has been 5 years now since tha happend.
thank you =)
Hi Beth, Unfortunately, it is likely that your arrest would appear on an Enhanced CRB Report. However, it is possible to dispute this.
For further free confidential advice on this please call me on 0161 278 2626
Regards,
David Wacks
Hi there… my partner has just served a 7 week sentence for embezzlement within his last employment. he has been in his current job for almost a year and as he had no charges at the time of applying for his new job never disclosed anything. He was taken to court and advised he would be given community service and made to pay it back. however he got given a custodial sentence and was immediately put into prison. therefore his job had given him unpaid absence as we bent the truth slightly about why he was in prison until he… Read more »
Dear Vee,
It will probably just mention a conviction under whatever act. He was convicted but, the police do have a discretion to add further detail as enhanced disclosure.
Despite recent changes in the law, his sentence means it will always come up on enhanced disclosure certificates, but, he can always appeal against the detail of enhanced disclosure being p ut to amplifythe mere fact of the conviction- enquire further need help on a certificate when he gets 1
hi my partner needs a crb check and is worried, he was done for GBH at the age of 13 after hitting back at a bully unfortunately he also hit a police officer. he is now 44 also 8 years ago his ex wife phone the police whilst he was in bed and told them he had hit her and he was taken into custody for the night but not charged with anything however his ex wife got a restraining order , this was later overturned by a judge and one given in his favor. will these show up on… Read more »
Hi Louise,
Your partners Conviction or Caution at the age of 13 is likely to come up on an Enhanced Disclosure search. If it was only a Caution an Application can be made to remove this although it is difficult.
If it is a Conviction, it will come up even now although “spent”.
The problem with his wife is likely to come up on an Enhanced Disclosure, but if it does an application can be made to review that.
If you do want further advice which is both free and confidential please call me.
David Wacks
0161 278 2626
Hi,i have several offences for fighting and criminal damage the last been in 2007(5 yrs ago) yet i am a fulltime dad,have a sia licence and im currently working has a college caretaker..im awaitng a enhanced crb check has ive got a new job working nights at a hostel with kids..ive obviously changed my ways but im still a little worried but would i have my sia and caretaker job in the first place if im gunna fail a check?. thanks
Hi Gavin,
I am delighted that you have a job, but do fear your old conviction will come up on an Enhanced Search even though, depending on your sentence, it may be spent for most other purposes.
If so, it is usually best to be up front but if you or other readers do want any initial free telephone advice please call me on my NEW direct line number 0161 278 2626.
Regards
David Wacks
Hi I’m currently awaiting to hear if I have got a job in an IT company doing work on customer financing. As part of this because you have access to financial data a CRB check is done.
18 years ago when I was 18 I was caught stealing and just given a police warning. Would it be a basic CRB check or enhanced? And will this show up on any of these?
Hi Louise, Unfortunately this will come up on any CRB. If you can show “exceptional circumstances” the Police may remove a Caution.
I am a Solicitor, if you require a free initial consultation you can call me on 0161 862 9103
Regards
David Wacks
I have have had many CRB checks for position I have worked in, However I feel I am never going to be allowed to put my past behind me, I got into trouble as a young man, last offence over 30 years ago! nothing to do with children or sexual offences, simply some fights as a young man defending myself. Ironicly I was abused as a child, and the defence mechanism I develloped was one as a source of protection from people wanting to hurt me, I must add, none of the abuse was from my family, it was neighbours,… Read more »
Dont pay over the odds, CRB advanced is only 36 pounds, a std one is 32 pounds, so make sure you either get your own from a google search or let them know you know how much they reallllllly do cost.
I have have had many CRB checks for position I have worked in, However I feel I am never going to be allowed to put my past behind me, I got into trouble as a young man, last offence over 30 years ago! nothing to do with children or sexual offences, simply some fights as a young man defending myself. Ironicly I was abused as a child, and the defence mechanism I develloped was one as a source of protection from people wanting to hurt me, I must add, none of the abuse was from my family, it was neighbours,… Read more »
how would i know that my employer had really do a CRB check on me…coz when i apply for a job as a support worker, they employ me straight away, and been on my own going to client’s houses after 2 days of being with someone for shadowing. and after that something like 10 days working, i left the job because they dont pay me properly like mileage when travelling from client to client, and then i let my employer knows that i decided not to work with them, and she said i’m going to be paying for the CRB… Read more »
I recently had an enhanced CRB check which came back clear and am already working for the organisation concerned. My CRB was clear, but management and some of my colleagues have been treating me differently since it came through as if they have other concerns. The only thing I can put this down to is the fact I had quite bad depression many years ago and may well have been considered a risk to myself. I never told them about that as it was well in the past. There was no police invovement. Do these checks involve mental health services… Read more »